Unless this is the first time you have ever visited Rambling Ever On, you are well aware how much we love the music of NEEDTOBREATHE. Counting this article, we have published 8 articles covering their music, plus they have been mentioned in multiple other music related pieces over the years. We make no apologies for that. In our view, they have been one of the most consistently great bands over the last 20 years. When all is said and done, they will go down as one of the premiere bands of their era. That deserves all the love we can give.

Continuing our year of celebrating the band, with this being the 20th anniversary of their debut album, as well as the year that saw the release of their 10th studio album, today we are proud to present our official ranking of every NEEDTOBREATHE album. For the purposes of this article, we only considered their 10 studio albums, so no live albums or EP’s were included. Our staff voted and we received some outside help as well. We hope you enjoy reading our list as much as we enjoyed putting it together. To the list!

---

10. Caves (2023)

I like this album. The title track is very strong, bringing a lot of similar energy to their earlier days. “Reaching Out to Find You” and “Hideaway” are impressive standouts as well. Caves fell last in our rankings, however, because out of all NEEDTOBREATHE’s records, it feels the least cohesive. For better or worse, as a whole this album is their most mainstream style of sound, and it doesn’t strive to make any sort of definitive statement. We’ve written before how better song sequencing would serve to help this album a lot. Overall, Caves is a collection of songs I really like, but a collection I find relatively uninspiring and forgettable in comparison to their other work. (Aidan)

9. Daylight (2006)

I chose to write about Daylight, NEEDTOBREATHE’s debut album, because of all of our staff, I was the one who found them first. Yes, I am that awesome. The first NEEDTOBREATHE song I ever heard was “You Are Here” while driving around Nashville listening to Christian radio. The song hooked me immediately and when I got home, I knew I had to find out who this band was.

After some frustrating searches (it wasn’t as easy back then to find out this stuff), I finally discovered the band was NEEDTOBREATHE. I had never heard of them so I looked up their discography. They only had one album, Daylight, so I proceeded to listen to the couple of tracks that were available online at that time. I needed to make sure they weren’t one of those bands that released their best song, while the rest of their stuff was terrible.

The first song I listened to when I got home was “Don’t Wait for Daylight”, the opener of the album, and that was all I needed. To this day, I consider it one of the best songs the band has made. It told me everything I needed to know about NEEDTOBREATHE: They were talented. They were passionate. And they weren’t afraid to rock. I bought the CD, not realizing this newfound band was about to become my favorite band in the world for the next 20 years.

That’s a lot of words and almost none of them are about the actual album. I will say this then. Daylight is clearly a debut album. It’s a young band throwing everything they have to create epic rock and roll. When it works, the title track, “More Than”, Shine On”, “You Are Here”, “Haley”, and “Lost”, it absolutely works. When it doesn’t work, you can feel the youth and inexperience. Daylight was a strong enough debut to make me take notice. I’m so glad I was listening to the radio that day. (Phill)

8. The Long Surrender (2026)

I don’t think we can properly rank this album. Having only spent a few weeks with these songs it is difficult to compare it to albums we’ve had years or even decades to appreciate and dissect. Five or Ten years from now we may look back and regret where this ended up on our list. Phill wrote a solid review of the record if you want more detailed thoughts of each track. I will keep my thoughts brief.

First, these may be the strongest lyrics the band has ever given us. These songs are vulnerable, honest, and mature in a way we’ve not seen before. This isn’t a knock on their previous work, NEEDTOBREATHE has always had excellent lyrics, but The Long Surrender is something special. Second, I wish they would rock more! I realize they are moving in a different direction musically and that is their prerogative, but I do miss the rock and roll from their earlier records. (Michael)

7. Into the Mystery (2021)

I strongly consider Into the Mystery to be one of NEEDTOBREATHE’s most underrated records. I was hooked from the first listen and it’s only grown on me ever since. It came out at the perfect time for me; it was the summer before going off to college and I was working a job I absolutely hated. Listening to this record on repeat after long shifts in the midst of huge life changes became second nature. 

From start to finish, all the songs work for me so well. Into the Mystery is the perfect blend of a campfire acoustic sound (“Carry Me”, “What I’m Here For”) with NEEDTOBREATHE’s signature southern rock energy (“I Am Yours”, “Innocence”.) The songs are written passionately and authentically, marking the first time in the band’s history that Bear handled the bulk of the songwriting. The band’s unique background vocals work as well as they have in the past, and you can feel a calm confident fun in the music they are making. 

The closer, “West Texas Wind,” is one of my favorite songs in the band’s entire discography. “Carry Me” and “I Wanna Remember” feature huge guests (Switchfoot and Carrie Underwood, respectively.) “I Am Yours”–a track that feels like the perfect sequel to “Who Am I” on their previous record–shoots for the stars and doesn’t miss. For an album the band wrote and recorded during lockdown from the pandemic, Into the Mystery fires on all cylinders, and the band doesn’t miss a beat. (Aidan)

6. Out of Body (2020)

Out of Body has always felt like a more natural successor to Rivers in the Wasteland than HARD LOVE was, and for that reason, it landed much higher on my personal list than it did for our other voters. I absolutely loved the energy of this album from my first listen, and I’ve only grown fonder of it over time.

NEEDTOBREATHE was in the middle of the biggest transition of their career – making this album without Bo Rinehart, who was one of the primary songwriters for the band up until this point. While Bo has some writing credits on Out of Body, the majority of the sound and spirit of the album was shaped by the other members of the band.

Considering all of this, it is a surprisingly cohesive and focused collection of songs. From the incredible powerhouse opener, “Mercy’s Shore” (which is one of the best live songs the band has ever done), to the emotionally and spiritually rich “Who Am I”, the band proves yet again it has the goods.

Out of Body has all the hallmark NEEDTOBREATHE elements: Bear’s one-of-a-kind vocal power. Great harmonies (the beautiful closer, “Seasons”). Southern rock swagger (“Survival” – featuring Drew and Ellie Holcomb), but with plenty of pop rock sensibility (“Banks” – the ballad that captured the heart of every middle-aged woman). There is not a weak track on the album, and its highs (“Bottom of a Heartbreak” – one of the best songs in their entire discography) are as good as anything the band has produced. (Phill)

5. The Heat (2007)

The Heat sits between the anthem rock of the band’s debut album and the roots rock sound they explore on their third album The Outsiders. Maybe this album doesn’t know exactly what it wants to be, but what we end up with is a very enjoyable listen. I mostly ignored this record when it was released and really only went back and paid attention to it after The Outsiders was released in 2009. I think one reason for my initial indifference to the album is a track sequencing problem. All the best songs are on the second half of the record!

Track 7 – “More Time” serves as kind of a dividing line. The song gives voice to the plea of a working musician struggling to make ends meet. After this we get a couple of strong radio singles, “Washed by the Water” and “Signature of Divine (Yahweh)” a pair of classic NEEDTOBREATHE anthems “Looks Like Love” and “Nothing Left to Lose,” the quirky title track, and a solid ballad to close the album in “Second Chances.” The only misstep on the second half of the record is “Moving On,” and I think I will do just that before I say something unkind about the song.

The Heat isn’t NEEDTOBREATHE’s best album, but it gives us a glimpse to where the band was headed and captures some of the magic they would more fully harness in upcoming records. (Michael)

4. HARD LOVE (2016)

You can generally trace the evolution of a band from album to album. As artists grow more confident in their sound or decide to explore new territory they usually build on what they have done before. Every once in a while, an artist will throw their fans a curveball and HARD LOVE is the first curveball in the NEEDTOBREATHE catalog. It is also the final album with co-founder Bo Rinehart as a member of the band.

Right before the album came out, I remember reading an article where the band discussed how their music wasn’t accessible enough and they often made their fans “work” too much to appreciate their songs. (For what it’s worth, I don’t really agree with this assessment of their sound.) They promised that Hard Love would be different. Well, they were not wrong!

The album is the most upbeat, pop record the band has ever released. Based on where it landed in our rankings we appreciate this detour but are glad this isn’t the musical territory where the guys spend most of their time. The album is a lot of fun, though, whether they choose to go upbeat (“Great Night,” “Happiness,” “Hard Love”) or choose to slow things down (“Clear,” “Be Here Long”). Hard Love may not have aged as well as some of their earlier work, but it is still a quality record that is worth revisiting. (Michael)

3. Rivers in the Wasteland (2014)

How do you follow two albums as commercially and critically successful as The Outsiders and The Reckoning? Where most bands tend to have their fall back to Earth after living in the highs of music this monumental, NEEDTOBREATHE crafts one of the most contemplative and reflective works in their catalog. Where The Outsiders is NEEDTOBREATHE’s triumphant statement of identity and The Reckoning is their crowning confident masterpiece, Rivers in the Wasteland is the perfect succession to an album trajectory of this nature. It’s much quieter than its predecessors, reflecting on where their careers have taken them and reaching out to find where they need to go next. 

Musically, Rivers in the Wasteland taps into a well NEEDTOBREATHE hadn’t yet pursued. The opening title track “Wasteland” and the closer “More Heart Less Attack” adds new layers of soft instrumentation that help the songs reach a deeply emotional level of melodic and ambient depth. “State I’m In”, “Feet Don’t Fail Me Now,” and “The Heart” are instant toe tapping classics that are infectiously fun to hear live. “Brother,” the band’s most popular song, and “Multiplied” are two of the band’s strongest songs and they work wonderfully to begin thematically closing the album. Rivers in the Wasteland is an all-time great album that displays some of the best of NEEDTOBREATHE’s talents from beginning to end. (Aidan)

2. The Outsiders (2009)

Fans of NEEDTOBREATHE knew the band had greatness in them. We could feel it in their debut album. We saw even more glimmers of it on their sophomore release, The Heat. But we also knew the band had not put it all together yet, but they were close. The Outsiders was the moment we all realized the wait was over. The band knew exactly who they were and they were eager to let everyone hear. It wasn’t a reinvention. Not at all. It was a coming of age. It was a fulfillment of the promise of their previous albums. The Outsiders was NEEDTOBREATHE at their most authentic, their most focused, and their most confident.

If you were a fan of their previous albums, The Outsiders felt like the natural next step. Even so, the artistry on display was a bit shocking. Yet, as stated previously, this was still 100% NEEDTOBREATHE. The Outsiders was filled with their signature sounds, hooks, and emotions. It was just a better and more mature vision.

As they did with The Heat, they incorporated a variety of instruments to fill every corner of sound with something to enjoy. Banjo, mandolin, harmonica, organ, and piano are all in heavy rotation throughout the album. From the gospel-infused “Lay ‘Em Down” to the beautiful bluegrass duet “Stones Under Rushing Waters” with Sarah Watkins of Nickel Creek fame, the band refused to be categorized or boxed in.

In the mood for a toe-tapping, rockabilly tune? “Girl Named Tennessee” fit the bill quite nicely. Looking for an 80s Peter Gabriel/U2 mash-up, with pounding drums and big vocals, “Through Smoke” was the song for you. Did you simply want to be inspired? “Something Beautiful” took care of that.

Nearly every song on the 14-song album worked and they more than made up for the weaker tracks with songs like “Prisoner”, the infectious number that had my entire family dancing around the house like idiots, and the cascading anthem, “Let Us Love”, whose last-minute left turn was inspiring and a bit shocking. It was a daring choice, and I applaud them for it.

Lyrically, their songs had never been more poetic or relevant. The album dealt with themes of faith amidst doubt, not conforming to the world’s expectations, and standing your ground in the face of opposition. The album had an openness that was lacking in many mainstream pop albums. It was mature work by a band who had become comfortable in their own skin.

NEEDTOBREATHE made an album that was impossible to classify, yet completely accessible. The Outsiders positioned them for big-time success, and it did so by digging deeper into who they were as musicians, not by selling out. NEEDTOBREATHE had arrived and the view truly was something beautiful. (Phill)

1. The Reckoning (2011)

I was fully expecting greatness from The Reckoning when it came out. The Outsiders is a GREAT album. No asterisk or addendums needed. The band that made that album clearly had the skill and the drive to push themselves even more to make an album that would be their crowning jewel. I believe they accomplished that with The Reckoning. The album feels like a band, totally confident in their abilities, attempting to create their masterpiece. They aimed for the sky and reached the heavens.

In a previous piece we published about the album, my brother Michael wrote this about it:

Of all their records this feels the most like they were trying to make a great album and were not concerned with radio singles. It’s more cohesive. I am not saying this to criticize their other work or even to criticize radio singles, but this one, as you said, was an attempt to “create their masterpiece.”

The album is full confidence, full bravado from the very first track, “Oohs and Ahhs”. It’s a swaggering, self-assured number that sets the tone immediately. It serves as an announcement that this album will be darker and moodier, but also that the band is not playing around. They mean business. They are too good and too talented to hide behind false modesty.

The Reckoning is more than just confidence, though; the album is satisfyingly complex but not in a showy way. They stretch themselves as writers and as musicians, and the musical palette of the album is enormous. They play with all the cards they possess on this one and you can hear it on every song. Considering The Reckoning is 14 songs, it has no throw away songs, no filler. It is absolutely complete. I love it when bands give their fans as much music as possible, but it’s rare that each musical offering is of the highest quality. The Reckoning starts off with a bang and never lets up.

The album is overflowing with honesty and vulnerability. “White Fences”, “Able”, and “Maybe They’re On to Us” strip off all defenses and lay bare the hearts of the band. And for wonderful counterprogramming, there are plenty of energetic anthems from the band, with “Drive All Night”, “Keep Your Eyes Open”, and “Devil’s Been Talkin’” doing some of the heavy lifting. But one element that really makes The Reckoning shine, is the quality of the deep cuts. Songs like “Tyrant Kings”, “Wanted Man”, and “Learn To Love” are all really late in the track listing, but they land as hard as anything else on the album.

The Reckoning is the band’s best album. It’s more mature, more confident, and more fully realized than any of their other albums. It’s a 14 song tour de force that 99% of bands could only dream of pulling off. It has all the signature NEEDTOBREATHE elements, but it adds complexity and depth to every song, every arrangement, and every lyric. It’s such a powerful statement, it landed at number 7 in our Top 100 Christian Rock Albums list from a few years ago.

It’s long been my contention that creating crowd-pleasing rock and roll that doesn’t pander is a much tougher task than most people realize. NEEDTOBREATHE is the rare band that does that in an almost effortless manner. The Reckoning is the perfect embodiment of that ethos. Come for the crowd-pleasing numbers. Stay for the songs that will shake your heart and soul. (Phill Lytle)

FINAL THOUGHTS

Well, that’s our list. As always, we are sure almost no one will completely agree with our rankings, but we hope you enjoyed reading our thoughts about each album. If you are feeling particularly gregarious, post your list in the comment section or on any of our social media platforms. We always love to hear from our readers. Until next time!