Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Literature

7 Times “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” Book Made Me Literally Laugh Out Loud

As endearing, tearjerking and Gospel-centered as Barbara Robinson’s classic book “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” is (and, indubitably, both the 1983 special as well as Dallas Jenkins’ 2024 full-length movie), one of its most triumphant attributes is its humor. It’s not just “smile big” or “chuckle briefly” humor at something cute or mischievous one of the kids in the book does, either. No, there are times I am reading the book out loud to my sons and I start laughing so hard that I can’t get it together to keep going. I literally laugh out loud at this book. Multiple times every reading.

Robinson has a sharp wit, and it comes out in her writing frequently. What truly amazes me is that since we started reading this as a family four Christmases ago, we have read it 12-15 times total, including once this year already. And yet, I never fail to laugh boisterously. And I love this because normally books do not make me laugh quite so hard, not nearly the way TV and movies do. It requires a special skill, to me at least, to make a person constantly laugh out loud in print.

But she achieves it perhaps to a level no other author ever has, at least per capita for length. My copy of this book is 108 pages, and the laughter comes every few pages. I hasten to add that, the way it is written, I do think reading it out loud during our family reading time makes the laughter bigger. Her writing style hits the ear in just the perfect way.

So, with that, here are seven times the book has caused me to pause reading to my sons so I could try to stop laughing:

“Oh we had a bed,” Ralph said, “only Ollie was still in it and he wouldn’t get out. He didn’t like Gladys.” He elbowed Ollie. “Remember how you didn’t like Gladys?”
I thought that was pretty smart of Ollie, not to like Gladys right off the bat.

The use of a narrator was brilliant for this story, and few places as hilarious as this one. This is the part that in our most recent reading that nearly had me rolling on the floor.

Beside being a fat kid, Wanda was a rich kid, so every time you turned around she had a new charm.
“Look at my new charm,” she would say. “It cost $6.95 without the tax. It’s a bird, and when you push this little knob, its wings flutter. It cost $6.95”

If my son Liam wants to make me laugh, he will say, “It cost $6.95” with a distinct, boastful, has-to-be-Wanda way of speaking. The repetition of the cost just kills us. Robinson gave every single character in the book such a clear “voice”. Even the secondary characters.

“I’ve got the baby here,” Imogene barked at the Wise Men. “Don’t touch him! I named him Jesus.”

Imogene is probably the funniest character in this book, if you don’t count the narration as a character, and this is a huge reason why. She’s so raw and real it’s refreshing, even if she does come at things with a bit of hubris.

Mother said, “And here’s the Herdman family. We’re so glad to see you all,” which was probably the biggest lie ever said right out loud in the church.

The honesty of this girl in telling this story is so good. And timeless. This book is almost 55 years old and it’s just as funny to me as it was when I read it as a youth.

“….Joseph and Mary, his espoused wife, being great with child…”
“Pregnant!” yelled Ralph Herdman.

The honesty of the Herdmans when learning about the original Christmas story compliments the honesty of the narrator marvelously. This is truly a story, at its heart, of children reacting without a filter (as kids are wont to do) to the craziest things imaginable1. From Jesus’s birth in ancient history to the Herdmans in church in present day.

I grew up watching this TV special the same as watching Charlie Brown, the Grinch and Frosty. Even before I ever read the book. And just like the book and the modern movie, it makes me laugh out loud repeatedly.

“We don’t show Herod in our pageant,” Mother said. And they all got mad. They wanted somebody to be Herod so they could beat him up.

The Herdmans reaction to Herod is a masterstroke of a plot twist and I love it with my whole heart. It is an insane moment where their love for violence collides with their newfound love for Jesus (and, appropriately, justice). The whole Herdman transformation reaches its crescendo during the actual pageant, but their obsession with toppling Herod during the first practice is a powerful first verse and it floods me with joy like nothing else in Christmas fiction. And I adore the fact they actually go to the library and read about him and discover things even the church people in the story didn’t know. it’s the most beautiful thing, told in the most hilarious way.

“They’re ruining the whole thing!” Alice whispered, but they weren’t at all. It made perfect sense for the wise men to sit down and rest, and I said so. “They’re supposed to have come a long way. You wouldn’t expect them to show up, hand over the ham, and leave!”2

I always cry hard while reading or watching any of the versions of this story and this is one of those scenes. The boys bringing ham instead of the actual wise men gifts is so pure, stunning and heart-wrenching, I ugly cry about every time. It’s such a Malachi 1:6-14 thing and the boys have no idea what Malachi 1 even says or means. And then the narrator says this and I’m laughing out loud and weeping at the same time.

And let me add, that I don’t think art gets any better than when you are doing both at the same time. And the fact all of this is centered around the real-world Gospel…this is peak entertainment to me.

There are so many other things that make me laugh, from the girl passing out from whistling in the pageant that one year, to Imogene growing angrier and angrier about Jesus’s birth circumstances, wondering about Child Welfare, but these are the funniest parts, in my opinion. If you have read the book, or even if you have watched either or both movies, what parts make you laugh the hardest? Please share below!

  1. Remember, the whole thing truly starts when Charlie gets up in front of the whole church and shamelessly proclaims something no adult would ever say—the best thing about church is no Herdmans. ↩
  2. In Jenkins’ version, at this point Alice says, “They didn’t bring ham!” Which is equally as funny. ↩
Gowdy Cannon

Discover more from Rambling Ever On

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Gowdy Cannon

I am currently the founder of The Canon Connected, a Bible Reading Plan and Podcast based on studying Bible Passages that connect to and interpret each other. It is found on social media everywhere, specifically sites like Facebook, Youtube, Instagram, Spotify and Apple. I formerly pastored at Bear Point Church in Sesser, IL for six years and before that served for 17 years as the associate bilingual pastor at Northwest Community Church in Chicago. My wife, Kayla, and I have been married 11 years and have a 7-year-old son, Liam Erasmus, and a three-year-old, Bo Tyndale. I have been a student at Welch College in Nashville and at Moody Theological Seminary in Chicago. I love The USC (the real one in SC, not the other one in CA), Seinfeld, John 3:30, Chick-fil-A, Dumb and Dumber, the book of Job, preaching and teaching, and arguing about sports.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.